Skip to content
MN Fish Finder

Silver

Otter Tail County
Near Frazee
DOW: 56022400
Yellow PerchGood · 74WalleyeGood · 70Largemouth BassGood · 50

A 239-acre lake near Frazee in Otter Tail County — best known for panfish and walleye. Last surveyed 2007.

Fish Species (14)

Yellow Perch

Good · 74

Typical numbers · large fish

Gill-net survey · surveyed Aug 1989

Last surveyed 1989 — treat with caution

Avg Weight
0.56 lbs

Catch rate: 9.5 per gill net · typical 2–22.3 for a lake like this

Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20070.335.7"0.12 lbs
Aug 2, 19890.50-0.50 lbs
Aug 2, 19899.50-0.56 lbs

Walleye

Good · 70

Typical numbers · large fish

Gill-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
20.8"
Avg Weight
3.12 lbs

Catch rate: 1.7 per gill net · typical 0.8–3.8 for a lake like this

Size of catchable walleye100% keeper-size (15"+)
All keeper-sizeLargest sampled 25"
Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20071.6720.8"3.12 lbs
Jul 30, 20070.3320.8"4.46 lbs
Aug 2, 19891.75-5.81 lbs

Largemouth Bass

Good · 50

Large fish

Gill-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
12.6"
Avg Weight
1.36 lbs

Catch rate: 2.0 per gill net · typical 0.3–0.6 for a lake like this

Size of catchable largemouth bass87% keeper-size (12"+)
8–11" · 13%Largest sampled 18"
Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20072.0012.6"1.36 lbs
Jul 30, 20070.4412.6"1.50 lbs
Aug 2, 19890.50-1.95 lbs

Northern Pike

Average · 48

Above-normal numbers · small fish

Gill-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
18.8"
Avg Weight
1.56 lbs

Catch rate: 21.0 per gill net · typical 2–10.8 for a lake like this

Size of catchable northern pike6% keeper-size (24"+)
14–23" · 94%Largest sampled 28"
Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 200721.0018.8"1.56 lbs
Jul 30, 20073.2218.8"1.43 lbs
Aug 2, 198910.00-1.29 lbs

Green Sunfish

Average · 43

Below-normal numbers · average-size fish

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
5.0"
Avg Weight
0.15 lbs

Catch rate: 0.22 per trap net · typical 0.3–2.8 for a lake like this

Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20070.225.0"0.15 lbs

Pumpkinseed

Average · 35

Typical numbers · small fish

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
4.6"
Avg Weight
0.11 lbs

Catch rate: 5.6 per trap net · typical 0.7–6.5 for a lake like this

Size of catchable pumpkinseed0% keeper-size (8"+)
3–7" · 100%Largest sampled 7"
Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20073.174.6"0.14 lbs
Jul 30, 20075.564.6"0.11 lbs
Aug 2, 19892.00-0.25 lbs

Bluegill

Average · 25

Typical numbers · small fish

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
4.6"
Avg Weight
0.09 lbs

Catch rate: 19.2 per trap net · typical 3.5–57.1 for a lake like this

Size of catchable bluegill1% keeper-size (8"+)
3–7" · 99%Largest sampled 8"
Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20075.004.6"0.12 lbs
Jul 30, 200719.224.6"0.09 lbs
Aug 2, 198918.25-0.44 lbs

Hybrid Sunfish

Poor · 23

Below-normal numbers

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
7.0"
Avg Weight
0.33 lbs

Catch rate: 0.22 per trap net

Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20070.227.0"0.33 lbs
Aug 2, 19891.50-0.33 lbs

Black Crappie

Poor · 15

Below-normal numbers · small fish

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
5.8"
Avg Weight
0.22 lbs

Catch rate: 1.6 per trap net · typical 2.1–24.1 for a lake like this

Size of catchable black crappie0% keeper-size (10"+)
5–9" · 100%Largest sampled 9"
Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20070.835.8"0.07 lbs
Jul 30, 20071.565.8"0.22 lbs
Aug 3, 19830.50-0.35 lbs
Other species in this lake (5)

Rough fish, bullheads, and baitfish recorded in DNR surveys — present in the lake, but not typical angling targets.

Yellow Bullhead

Good · 63

Typical numbers · average-size fish

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
9.0"
Avg Weight
0.49 lbs

Catch rate: 6.8 per trap net · typical 1–7.1 for a lake like this

Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 200711.179.0"0.43 lbs
Jul 30, 20076.789.0"0.49 lbs
Aug 2, 19890.25-0.80 lbs

White Sucker

Good · 58

Typical numbers · average-size fish

Gill-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
17.4"
Avg Weight
2.00 lbs

Catch rate: 1.5 per gill net · typical 0.5–2.3 for a lake like this

Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20071.5017.4"2.00 lbs
Jul 30, 20070.3317.4"2.12 lbs
Aug 2, 19890.25-4.00 lbs

Common Carp

Good · 50

Large fish

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
20.5"
Avg Weight
4.68 lbs

Catch rate: 0.22 per trap net · typical 0.4–2.4 for a lake like this

Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20070.2220.5"4.68 lbs

Brown Bullhead

Average · 47

Typical numbers · average-size fish

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
9.7"
Avg Weight
0.49 lbs

Catch rate: 1.3 per trap net · typical 0.4–5.1 for a lake like this

Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20070.179.7"0.36 lbs
Jul 30, 20071.339.7"0.49 lbs
Aug 2, 198960.25-0.50 lbs

Black Bullhead

Poor · 23

Below-normal numbers · average-size fish

Trap-net survey · surveyed Jul 2007

Last surveyed 2007 — treat with caution

Avg Size
8.4"
Avg Weight
0.31 lbs

Catch rate: 0.11 per trap net · typical 1.5–58 for a lake like this

Survey History
DateCatch RateAvg LengthAvg Weight
Jul 30, 20076.178.4"0.40 lbs
Jul 30, 20070.118.4"0.31 lbs
Aug 2, 198949.50-0.22 lbs

Biologist Notes

July 30, 2007Silver Lake is a 247-acre eutrophic (fertile) lake located in north central Otter Tail County approximately 2.5 miles east of the city Frazee. Silver…

Silver Lake is a 247-acre eutrophic (fertile) lake located in north central Otter Tail County approximately 2.5 miles east of the city Frazee. Silver Lake outlets into Murphy Lake by a non-navigable channel under county road 118. Silver Lake is part of the Otter Tail River watershed and the immediate watershed is composed primarily of marshland and hardwood lots interspersed with agricultural land. Silver Lake has a maximum depth of 34 feet; however 91% of the surface acreage is less than 15 feet deep. Shoal water substrates consist of sand and muck. The lake is sparsely developed. A DNR owned public water access is located on the north shoreline directly east of the outlet. The secchi disk reading in this survey was 5.5 feet. Previous secchi disk readings have ranged from 2.6 to 4.7 feet. Silver Lake is subject to periodic partial winterkill. Past partial winterkills have occurred during the winters of 1988-1989, 1992-1993, and 1996-1997. Silver Lake is included in lake class 38 of the MNDNR lake classification scheme. Other lakes in the Fergus Falls management area that are in lake class 38 include: Buchanan, Elbow, Prairie, Round, and Sand. Large areas of hardstem bulrush and common cattail are present around the lake. Emergent aquatic plants such as bulrush and cattail provide valuable fish and wildlife habitat, and are critical for maintaining good water quality. They protect shorelines and lake bottoms, and can actually absorb and break down polluting chemicals. Emergent plants provide spawning areas for fish such as northern pike, largemouth bass, and panfish. They also serve as important nursery areas for all species of fish. Because of their ecological value, emergent plants may not be removed without a DNR permit. Silver Lake is a classic bass/panfish lake, where there is little to no natural walleye reproduction occurring. Past walleye fry stockings weren't reaching the management goals so the current lake management plan calls for walleye fry stockings only after a partial winterkill occurs. The walleyes that were sampled during the 2007 assessment correspond to years that Murphy Lake was stocked with fry. At times Silver Lake can provide some excellent bluegill fishing. Bluegills are abundant and in past surveys showed good size structure. Even though only 10% of the bluegills sampled during the 2007 assessment were 7.0 inches or greater, a special spring trap net assessment in 2001 had 33% of the bluegill sample seven inches or greater. The northern pike abundance has greatly increased while the size structure has slowly improved from past surveys. Pike sampled by gill nets ranged in length form 13.2 to 28.8 inches with a mean length at capture of 19.4 inches. This was the first survey where northern pike over 24 inches were sampled. Seven percent of the northern pike sampled were 24 inches or greater. The increase in northern pike abundance appears to have had an impact on the yellow perch population, as this was the first survey where a yellow perch was not sampled by a gill net. Anglers can maintain the quality of angling by practicing selective harvest. Selective harvest encourages the release of medium to large-size fish while allowing the harvest of more abundant smaller fish for table fare. Releasing the medium to large fish will ensure that the lake will have enough spawning age fish on an annual basis and will provide anglers with more opportunities to catch large fish in the future.

August 2, 1989Silver Lake is subject to periodic winterkill. A partial winterkill occurred in the winter of 1988-89. The lake is very turbid with dense growths of s…

Silver Lake is subject to periodic winterkill. A partial winterkill occurred in the winter of 1988-89. The lake is very turbid with dense growths of submerged aquatic vegetation. Northern pike abundance increased from 4.0 per gill net lift in the 1983 survey to 10.0 per net with an average weight of 1.3 pounds. Northern pike ranged in age from 0+ to IV+. Black bullhead abundance remains high at 49.5 per gill net lift. Bluegill abundance is high. No bluegills were greater than 6.5 inches in length. Bluegills ranged in age from V+ to VII+. Growth rates of bluegill appear to be above average. Yellow perch abundance declined substantially from 76.5 per gill net lift in 1983 to 9.5 per net. Seven walleyes were sampled in trap nets, none in gill nets. All walleyes were greater than 20.0 inches in length and were aged at VII+ or older. No walleyes were sampled from the 1986 fry stocking.

August 3, 1983Silver Lake is susceptible to periodic winterkill. Test-netting data indicates that Silver Lake has a high-density population of black bullheads. Most…

Silver Lake is susceptible to periodic winterkill. Test-netting data indicates that Silver Lake has a high-density population of black bullheads. Most other species were represented in the sample but at a low abundance and small size. Walleye have not been stocked but there may be potential for fry stocking if an access is obtained. The yellow perch population was very high compared with the local median.

Frequently Asked Questions

What fish can you catch in Silver?

Based on Minnesota DNR survey data, anglers target Yellow Perch, Walleye, Largemouth Bass, Northern Pike, and Green Sunfish in Silver. See the full species list above for catch rates, size structure, and quality scores.

Is there public access at Silver?

Minnesota DNR records list public access for Silver. Check the DNR LakeFinder page for the launch type and directions before you go.

How deep is Silver?

Silver has a maximum depth of 34 feet, per Minnesota DNR data.

When were the main sport fish in Silver last surveyed?

The most recent Minnesota DNR survey data for the main sport fish in Silver is from 2007. Surveys this old should be treated with some caution — fish populations change over time.

Does Silver have any invasive species?

No invasive species are on record for Silver in Minnesota DNR data. Always clean, drain, and dry your equipment to help keep it that way.

More lakes in Otter Tail County

View all

Lake Details

Surface Area
238.73 acres
Max Depth
34 ft
Shoreline
2.6 mi
Public Access
Yes
View on DNR LakeFinder

Location

46.6981°N, 95.6592°W

Get Directions